UPtv has officially announced Season 2 of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries coming in 2027!
If you've been following any of the cast on social media, then you've likely seen them filming throughout the summer.
It is great now to get this official confirmation that UPtv will continue to bring us this series in 2027. Season 1 reached 1.8 million viewers and ranked as a Top 20 ad-supported cable series!
The new season also brings back the actors we loved from the first season: Galadriel Stineman, Denise Gossett, Kevin Joy and Riley Beeson.
See all the details in the press release below.
Press Release via UP Entertainment:
UPTV HIT SERIES
SUGARCREEK AMISH MYSTERIES
GREENLIT FOR A SECOND SEASON
ATLANTA (July 30, 2026) – UPtv, the television home for uplifting entertainment, has acquired season two of the hit series Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries. Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries blends cozy mystery, cultural discovery, and heartwarming reinvention in a series about finding family in unexpected places and uncovering the truest parts of ourselves. Season two gets right into the action as Cheryl Cooper (Galadriel Stineman) has found her footing in the Amish community in Sugarcreek, Ohio. Bigger locations and new thrilling mysteries will not only put Cheryl’s sharp instincts to the test, but also will question her place among the community she loves so dearly. Cheryl must decide if she follows her instincts and opens her heart to the possibility of love.
"What makes Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries so special is its ability to combine intrigue and suspense with the uplifting storytelling our viewers are seeking," said Crissie Miller, VP of Content Strategy and Planning. "Audiences have connected deeply with Cheryl, the Miller family and the sense of belonging at the heart of Sugarcreek. We can't wait to bring fans more mysteries and more of the characters they've come to love."
Season two will build on the stories and characters from the first season, including returning cast members Galadriel Stineman as Cheryl Cooper, Denise Gossett as Naomi Miller, Kevin Joy as Levi Miller and Riley Beeson as Esther Miller. Together, the team will uncover even more mysteries in the town of Sugarcreek. The new season is expected to premiere on UPtv in 2027.
According to Nielsen, Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries season one was viewed by 1.8 million viewers in its original run on UPtv. Across season one, 1st run telecasts averaged HH AA(000) 228 and W18+ AA(000) 180 which made the show a Top-20 Ad Supported Cable destination ranking 19th in HH delivery and 18th in Women18+ delivery.*
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries is directed by Sandra L. Martin and executive produced by Martin and Chevonne O’Shaughnessy.
*Source: Nielsen UBD L7 4/20/26-6/14/26; Unduplicated audience reach and TH 9p-10p time period rank versus All Ad Supported Cable networks.
About UP Entertainment
UP Entertainment is the home for uplifting entertainment for passionate and diverse audiences across the leading cable, satellite and streaming platforms. Brands include UP Faith & Family, UPtv, aspireTV, aspireTV+, GaitherTV+ and Cine Romántico. UP Faith & Family is the leading subscription streaming service for uplifting entertainment. UPtv is the trusted network for adults seeking positive programming with relatable stories about relationships, filled with love and laughter, through exclusive premiere movies, box-office hit films and beloved series. AspireTV is the television network that celebrates and reflects Black culture, life and style in a way that is inspiring, authentic and entertaining. AspireTV+ is a new subscription streaming service for Black culture and urban lifestyle entertainment. GaitherTV+ provides access to Gaither’s renowned and growing library of full-length award-winning Country, Gospel, Bluegrass and Christian concerts and specials, early premieres of new performances and shows, and exclusive behind-the-scenes interviews. UP Entertainment in partnership with PixL Dos, also manages and distributes Cine Romántico, a FAST channel featuring the best of Hollywood TV romance movies in Spanish. Additionally, UP Entertainment also represents partner brands Ovation TV. Ovation is an independent television, production, and digital media company, with an unparalleled commitment to the arts, culture and entertainment. UP Entertainment’s award-winning pro-social initiative, “UPlift Someone”, has inspired over 200 million people to uplift others through its social videos.
-----------------------
I hope many of you are looking forward to this new season of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries as much as I am!
Happy Sleuthing,
Net
images via: Galadriel Stineman
