Lori Loughlin is officially bringing the beloved Garage Sale Mystery series back to Hallmark Channel!
Lori shared this exciting and much anticipated announcement in a video on Instagram, revealing that the long-running mystery series will return in the fall of 2026. The new movie will premiere first on Hallmark Channel and will stream the next day on Hallmark+.
A total of 16 Garage Sale Mystery movies aired between 2013 and 2022, and now the case is officially back on!

So far, Hallmark hasn't revealed any casting details beyond Lori's return, which leaves us all back to our sleuthing.
We'll have to wait and see if Steve Bacic will reprise his role as Jason Shannon, Jennifer's husband, or if Sarah Strange will return as Dani, Jennifer's best friend and business partner at their antique shop.
It's also still unknown whether Eva Bourne will be back as Jennifer and Jason's daughter, Hannah Shannon, if Connor Stanhope will return as their son, Logan, or whether Kevin O'Grady will once again portray Detective Frank Lynwood.
I'm certainly hoping we'll get to see these familiar faces again. It just wouldn't feel quite the same without so many of the characters we've come to know and love!
Lori Loughlin's Announcement:
Hallmark hasn't announced an exact premiere date just yet, so for now, all we know is that the new "Garage Sale Mystery" will arrive sometime this fall. Until then, I guess we'll have to keep searching for more clues!
The new movie is currently filming and has the working title: Garage Sale Mysteries: She Took an Axe.
As many of you may remember, Hallmark ended its working relationship with Lori Loughlin in 2019 following the college admissions bribery scandal. Lori made her acting return as her beloved character Abigail Stanton in the When Hope Calls Christmas specials in 2021 on Great American Famiy, and earlier this year she stepped back into Abigail's shoes once again on the Hallmark Channel during the season 13 finale of When Calls the Heart. Hallmark has also announced that Lori will return for season 14 of the series.

It's been heartwarming to see so many fans and fellow actors welcoming Lori back with such kindness and open arms.
I'm certainly hoping this is only the first of many more Garage Sale Mystery movies to come!
The Complete Collection
16 Films on DVD
*Click here for DVD details*
*Click here to Stream*
Garage Sale Mysteries
via Hallmark+
screenshot via: Hallmark Media










Okay it took me a while but I remember reading something on Facebook. Liza Huget was congratulated by Lucas Talent Inc on Facebook for landing a role in the upcoming movie Garage Sale Mystery: She Took an Axe. In the film, she is set to play the supporting character Liza, the mother of a character named Jessica..
ReplyDeleteHallmark actually bringing back an old mystery series. Good sign for the future! -Maria
ReplyDeleteGreat! Now can they please bring back Mystery 101?! At least Garage Sale didn’t have a giant cliffhanger. And before anyone says Jill is with GAF, she has said multiple times that she wants to have closure for Mystery 101 too.
ReplyDelete