 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Today, Sleuthers, I am shining a light... uncovering ALL the Garage Sale Mystery Movies made - so far!
Track these details... as you will discover below - the chronological order of the "Garage Sale Mystery" movie series from 2013 (when it first premiered on the Hallmark Channel) to 2018, where it resides in it's home now on Hallmark Movies & Mysteries!
There have been some changes throughout the "Garage Sale Mystery" series, including every member of Jennifer Shannon's (portrayed by Lori Loughlin) family - from her husband, to her children! The role of Jason Shannon, Jennifer's husband, was first played by Rick Ravanello, but since the second movie, that role has been played by Steve Bacic. The daughter Hannah, was also portrayed by another actress in the pilot movie, Sara Canning, however Eva Bourne, after the first film, stepped into that role. Eva also portrays Lori Loughlin's daughter-n-law on "When Calls the Heart". Brendan Meyer starred as the son in the first three movies, up until "Garage Sale Mystery: The Deadly Room". When Brendan became involved in other acting projects, Connor Stanhope (who had also worked with Lori Loughlin on "When Calls the Heart") stepped into the role of Logan Shannon in "Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent".
 |
| The Shannon family... Connor Stanhope, Steve Bacic, Lori Loughlin, and Eva Bourne, "Garage Sale Mystery" - Hallmark Crown Media |
In addition to these changes, the role of Police Detective was first portrayed by Andrew Dunbar, who, by the way, dated Hannah in the pilot movie, and then returned in "Garage Sale Mystery: Murder Most Medieval" in a different role. The part of detective is now regularly filled by Kevin O'Grady, as the no-nonsense - Detective Frank Lynwood.
 |
| Kevin O'Grady and Lori Loughlin "Garage Sale Mystery" - Hallmark Crown Media |
Although there have been many cast changes (mostly early on), the heart of the story has remained the same, and one other role, besides Lori Loughlin's as Jennifer Shannon, has remained a constant, and that is Jennifer's friend and antique shop business partner Dani, played by the always interesting, Sarah Strange.
 |
| Sarah Strange and Lori Loughlin in "Garage Sale Mystery" - Hallmark Crown Media |
Now, the "Garage Sale Mystery" Movie Series in Chronological Order...
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #1: Garage Sale Mystery (pilot movie)
Premiere Date: September 14, 2013
Storyline via Hallmark: Jennifer Shannon (Loughlin) can always find a diamond in the rough - when it comes to garage sales, that is! Whether it's a new antique to sell at her consignment shop, an Atari game for her son, or a piece of furniture for her handy husband Jason (Ravanello) to refurbish, she has made a career out of her treasure-hunting prowess. When a string of burglaries hits her town, Jennifer's keen eye for detail and her natural problem-solving instincts even help her see the connection between these burglaries and local garage sales! Jennifer works with Detective Adam Iverson (Dunbar) to investigate her theory that the perpetrators of the burglaries are fellow garage sale regulars. The case escalates to dangerous levels when Jennifer discovers the dead body of her friend. Even though the deceased's husband, Ben Douglas (Bancroft), finds nothing missing in their house, and the police label the death as accidental, Jennifer suspects that the death may be related to the burglaries.
With just her treasure-hunting skills and problem-solving instincts, she finds and pieces together clues to the burglaries and her friend's death. As she gets closer to the truth, however, Jennifer discovers that crime-solving can be far more perilous than any garage sale. Can she uncover the "Garage Sale Mystery" before it's too late, or will her investigation create problems that not even Jennifer can solve?
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery for more images + details!
Also available in a DVD collection...
(There are 4 Films in this collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #2: Garage Sale Mystery: All that Glitters
Premiere Date: October 26, 2014
Storyline via Hallmark: A sleuthing garage sale maven gets embroiled in a criminal investigation when a storage facility is the scene of a murder and she is a key eyewitness.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: All that Glitters for more images + details!
Also available in a DVD collection...
(There are 4 Films in this collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #3: Garage Sale Mystery : The Deadly Room
Premiere Date: April 11, 2015
Storyline via Hallmark: A sleuthing garage sale maven suspects foul play when her friend dies in an old house with a cursed reputation. Even though police evidence - and even webcam footage of the death – point to natural causes – this mysterious death in a “cursed” home poised for multi-million dollar sale seems too coincidental. Putting her keen instincts to work, she examines a few key suspects. As she digs into this deadly mystery, she uncovers clues that bring her closer to the truth, and even put her own life in danger.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery : The Deadly Room for more images + details!
(There are 4 Films in this collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #4: Garage Sale Mystery: The Wedding Dress
Premiere Date: August 9, 2015
Storyline via Hallmark: Jennifer Shannon has made a career of finding rare garage sale treasures to resell at her consignment store. When she finds a wedding dress that was worn on the day a groom went missing, Jennifer uses her knack for solving puzzles to investigate this unsolved cold case. After finding traces of blood on the dress, Jennifer digs deeper into the decades-old mystery. With every clue that she uncovers, she gets closer to either finding the long-missing groom, or uncovering a wedding day murder.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: The Wedding Dress for more images + details!
(There are 4 Films in this collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #5: Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent
Premiere Date: January 3, 2016
Storyline via Hallmark: When Jenn's old pal Sandra becomes the prime suspect in a murder case, it'll be up to her to discover who done it before time runs out.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent for more images + details!
(There are 3 Films in this collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #6: Garage Sale Mystery: The Novel Murders
Premiere Date: June 5, 2016
Storyline via Hallmark: Jennifer Shannon (Lori Loughlin) is a garage sale shopping expert whose sharp observation skills allow her to uncover valuable antiques, as well as help her local police department solve mysteries. Jennifer is asked to make a home delivery for a customer, but she finds the recipient has been murdered. Jennifer soon realizes that the victim's cold-blooded demise is a re-enactment of a murder in a classic mystery novel. When Jennifer discovers connections between suspects and victims, and uncovers their ties to the literary world, she must race against time to solve the Novel Murders case, without becoming the killer's next victim.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: The Novel Murders for more images + details!
(There are 3 Films in this collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #7: Garage Sale Mystery: The Art of Murder
Premiere Date: January 8, 2017
Storyline via Hallmark: Jennifer Shannon is a garage sale shopping expert whose sharp observation skills allow her to uncover valuable antiques, as well as help her local police department investigate crimes and solve mysteries. While arranging a charity garage sale event, Jennifer finds a body in the attic of a local residence. At first, Jennifer, working alongside Detective Frank Lynwood, determines that the cause of death was an accidental fall. But when she learns that the victim was trying to call 911, she begins to suspect foul play. Though Lynwood remains convinced the fatality was an accident, Jennifer decides to investigate on her own, questioning key suspects, including Tina Parsons, an art appraiser and close friend of the deceased.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: The Art of Murder for more images + details!
(There are 3 Films in this collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #8: Garage Sale Mystery: The Beach Murder
Premiere Date: August 6, 2017
Storyline via Hallmark: A collection of valuable classic surfboards brings Jenn into this mystery after a young internet entrepreneur, Garrett Winters, is found drowned in the ocean, apparent victim of a surfing accident. His beautiful wife, Annie, comes to the store because Garrett had a collection of old and valuable surf boards. Annie doesn’t believe the death was accidental. She thinks someone killed her husband. Jenn’s detective abilities are pushed to the limit to solve this seemingly accidental death.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: The Beach Murder for more images + details!
(This is the complete Garage Sale Mystery collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #9: Garage Sale Mystery: Murder by Text
Premiere Date: August 13, 2017
Storyline via Hallmark: Famous country singer John Dalton's concert rehearsal is stalled when the entire crew receives a suicide note from Lita, the band’s bassist. After discovering that a Taser was used to immobilize her before her death, Jenn is skeptical that Lita’s death was actually suicide.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: Murder by Text for more images + details!
(This is the complete Garage Sale Mystery collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #10: Garage Sale Mystery: Murder Most Medieval
Premiere Date: August 20, 2017
Storyline via Hallmark: Jennifer finds the body of a local college history professor hidden in the 15th century suit of armor she purchased for a wealthy client. As she narrows down the number of murder suspects, Jennifer finds herself caught in the killer’s web of dangerous lies.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: Murder Most Medieval for more images + details!
(This is the complete Garage Sale Mystery collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #11: Garage Sale Mystery: A Case of Murder
Premiere Date: August 27, 2017
Storyline via Hallmark: Garage sale shopper extraordinaire and amateur sleuth Jennifer Shannon (Lori Loughlin) purchases an old tape recorder which holds a recording she suspects might be of an actual murder.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: A Case of Murder for more images + details!
(This is the complete Garage Sale Mystery collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #12: Garage Sale Mystery: The Pandora’s Box Murders
Premiere Date: August 5, 2018
Storyline via Hallmark: Garage sale guru and amateur sleuth Jennifer Shannon agrees to appear on a new reality TV series. During the show she comes in contact with a mysterious puzzle box, in which the box’s now-deceased creator may have placed the clue to her killer. When the dead woman’s daughter-in-law is found dead just a few days later, Jennifer’s curiosity once again places her in harm’s way as she embarks on her own unorthodox investigation of the murders.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: The Pandora’s Box Murders for more images + details!
(This is the complete Garage Sale Mystery collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #13: Garage Sale Mystery: The Mask Murder
Premiere Date: August 12, 2018
Storyline via Hallmark: Garage sale guru Jennifer Shannon (Loughlin) discovers a dead body in the storage locker she and business partner Dani (Strange) have purchased at auction. When further inspection of the locker’s contents reveals plaster “death masks,” and one of those masks perfectly matches the dead woman’s visage, Jennifer’s “inner sleuth” kicks into overdrive as she works to piece together the clues that will lead to the killer.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: The Mask Murder for more images + details!
(This is the complete Garage Sale Mystery collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #14: Garage Sale Mystery: Picture A Murder
Premiere Date: August 19, 2018
Storyline via Hallmark: After taking a vintage camera collection on consignment following the death of a local collector, garage sale guru and amateur sleuth Jennifer Shannon becomes involved in the search for a killer when an undeveloped photo in one of the cameras leads her to believe that the man might have died from very unnatural causes.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: Picture A Murder for more images + details!
(This is the complete Garage Sale Mystery collection!)
********************
 |
| image: Hallmark Crown Media |
Movie #15: Garage Sale Mystery: Murder in D Minor
Premiere Date: August 26, 2018
Storyline via Hallmark: When a local art collector dies and his expansive collection is auctioned off, garage sale guru and amateur sleuth Jennifer Shannon (Lori Loughlin) and business partner Dani (Sarah Strange) purchase a rare piece. However, when the provenance of the entire collection comes into question, and Jennifer determines that the man may have a secret stash of ill-gotten treasures hidden away, she finds herself investigating a pre-meditated murder.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: Murder in D Minor for more images + details!
(This is the complete Garage Sale Mystery collection!)
********************
Movie #16: Garage Sale Mystery: Searched & Seized
Premiere Date: February 5, 2023
Storyline via Hallmark: Jennifer Shannon agrees to help fellow antique dealer Miles Wexford by bidding on items at a police auction on his behalf. When he turns up dead, she investigates a counterfeiter with mob ties.
*See my original post on Garage Sale Mystery: Searched & Seized for more details!
(This is the complete Garage Sale Mystery collection!)
"Garage Sale Mystery" is certainly a fascinating series with the Shannon family elements and intriguing who-dun-it's!
Hope all of you Sleuthers join me, in watching these mysteries!
Stay tuned!!!
Net
Net
**🔎🔎🔎**
Thanks for posting this. Up to this point, my favorite has been The Novel Murders, but I believe Murder Most Medieval will become my new favorite since my friend Sebastian Spence is in the cast. Very excited for next week!
ReplyDeleteAwesome breakdown of the movies! So good to know there will be more!
ReplyDeleteMisty
I am glad to hear there are more of these being made! I think this series is my favorite of the murder mysteries with Aurora Teagarden a very close 2nd.
ReplyDeletethanks for this post. I really enjoy these movies. I am very glad that they aren't stopping. I had misheard a commercial last night and thought the last one they were showing this month was THE last one.
ReplyDeleteLori Loughlin is the best ambassador for Hallmark! I love her and all her movies! Happy to hear there are plans to make more.
ReplyDeleteNot anymore
DeleteStill love her and her movies.
DeleteThanks for posting all of these. I really had no idea there were so many of them. I thought I had seen them all, but I noted a few of them.
ReplyDeleteI love Lori's mystery movies! Thanks for posting this informative listing for GSM, Net!
ReplyDeletedo you know if they are all available to buy as a set?
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately, the Garage Sale Mystery movies aren't available all in one DVD set, but I think that would be wonderful - if they chose to do that one day! Or, at least, please keep releasing them singularly, right?
DeleteThank you for asking, Desirae, and visiting my site!
Blessings, Net
When are these mystery movies going to be on dvd, homely region free for everyone around the world. Thank you for listening to my opinion.
ReplyDeleteYes, I agree, Margaret, it has been surprising how little of these movies are available on DVD, especially being such a popular series for Hallmark Movies & Mysteries! I think it would be awfully nice if they released several of them in a set, like they did with "Murder She Baked"!
DeleteThank you for sharing! Blessings, Net
Love the Garage Sale Mysteries!! Can't wait until August.
ReplyDeleteThe Garage Sale Mysteries are in my opinion not only the best, they are the only ones worth watching.
ReplyDeleteIt's too bad that such a great series has to be ruined for everybody because of one person's greed. I really, really, enjoyed these movies and am heartbroken to have lost them because Ms Laughlin couldn't play by the rules... Every other character has been replaced on this sreies (except Miss Strange). Why not replace Ms Laughlin and continue the series. If most fans love it as much as I do, they will continue to follow
ReplyDeleteJust thought you might like to k ow how one fan feels.
Sherry Wilkin
Utterly ridiculous all the cast changes. Also having the same actor play the police officer in the first movie and then a different character in the Medieval movie really poor.
ReplyDeleteAs for Lori's behaviour and everything being cancelled.... wish I'd never started these. Hallmark has really failed with this. They cast new people every 5 mins - so replace Lori.
Just don’t watch it if you don’t like her. I happen to love the series! As it says in the Bible those without sin cast the first stone.
DeleteLori hasn't been convicted of anything yet that I know of. If she has learned her leason why not bring her back. God has forgiven me for all my sins. I think it is right to forgive her for hers and give her another chance.
ReplyDeleteWhy not replace Lori and continue the series?
ReplyDeleteWould be GREAT to have more of these movies made NOW.
ReplyDeleteLove Lori Loughlin and her acting. Blessings 🌸
I agree!!! I'm so glad that Hallmark has been replaying these movies. I'm sure there are so very many of us who'd happily watch this cast in more Garage Sale Mysteries
ReplyDeleteI agree, I would love to see more Garage Sale Mysteries
ReplyDeleteI wish they would make more of these with Lori.
ReplyDeleteI feel the same way, Anonymous. I'd bet it would be a huge success too!!
Delete