"Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries" - My Review of Episode 3 - airing on UPtv

Hey, friends... I had the opportunity to watch an early screener of the third episode of "Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries" titled "O Little Town of Sugarcreek," and I just had to share that this episode was my favorite one yet!

No spoilers, I promise, but here are a few (or more!) of my favorite details...

⚫ First, these mysteries (so far) are simple mysteries within the town of Sugarcreek that do not involve murder. This episode is about missing jewelry.

⚫ While we've seen Cheryl Cooper's adorable cat, Beau, before, he makes more of an appearance in this episode.

⚫ This series is definitely giving me vibes of the Hallmark series, Mistletoe Murders - the lead women in both series have red hair, and they both own a small store within a quaint town that sells small gifts, knick-knacks, home decor, etc. Both women have cats and employ a teenage girl related to their supposed love interest, and their love interests often help to solve mysteries.

⚫ In this episode of "Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries," there's a bit of a romantic love triangle when Cheryl's ex, Lance, makes a surprise visit!

⚫ And best of all, for this episode, which you might be able to tell from the title, "O Little Town of Sugarcreek," is centered around the Christmas season! It's interesting to see how this quaint Amish town celebrates the holiday; it's even mentioned that their main focus is to celebrate the birth of their Lord!

Storyline via UPtv: Christmas thefts and a returned ex force Cheryl to protect an innocent friend and her heart.

Here's a little sneak-peek:

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

airs Thursday, May 7, 2026

at 9pm/8c. on UPtv

If you prefer to stream, "Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries" can also be seen on UP Faith & Family - *click here for details*.

For more Christmas programming, visit the Christmas Schedule!

Happy sleuthing,

Net🔎